How To Choose The Right Insurance Lawyer

insurance lawyer

Whenever people suffer losses from theft, fire, or other calamities and file an insurance claim, they naturally feel stressed and confused as they are unaware of their rights and are unsure whether they will receive the payout they desire. Insurance is a negotiation; you might have to fight for it even if you have paid for your coverage.

Insurance lawyers can be of great help when dealing with insurance firms. Those who find it difficult to understand the policies and technicalities associated with insurance companies would particularly benefit from hiring these professionals. Insurance attorneys handle all your insurance matters on your behalf and streamline the entire process, improving your chances of getting a favourable outcome.

In this guide, we want to learn more about insurance lawyers in the US, their specialties, and more, and discuss how much it costs to hire these attorneys and how you can find the right lawyer for your requirements.

Understanding Insurance Lawyers – A Complete Guide

The law associated with insurance is quite complex and challenging to understand. Insurance lawyers are specialized professionals experienced in this area of law and know how to deal with the nuances involved. These attorneys provide legal assistance to business owners, enterprises, and individuals when faced with a challenging situation related to insurance.

Insurance lawyers work to protect the rights of individuals and businesses in correspondence with an insurance claim. They help answer queries about fairness regarding insurance policies and contracts. They handle various aspects of insurance claims, from accidental claims to negotiations, and ensure their clients don’t receive less or pay more than they should.

These attorneys help individuals who fail to get compensation from their insurance provider. They also act as arbiters between companies and employees whenever a disagreement or conflict is associated with coverage. They can even represent insurance providers and help them achieve the desired outcome for a case related to client insurance coverage.

Insurance Lawyers & Their Specialties

Insurance lawyers are those practicing in the area of insurance law. They provide legal advice and assistance whenever individuals or organizations have questions or confusion regarding an insurance claim or want help negotiating settlements with insurance companies. They also represent their clients in court when an insurance matter becomes a lawsuit.

Insurance lawyers have different specialties depending on the type of claims they handle.

  • Bad Faith Insurance

    This type of insurance lawyer represents policyholders for claims against providers that refuse to pay a claim wrongfully or have denied a claim without proper investigation.

  • Insurance Defense

    These attorneys focus on insurance-related issues and help clients understand when they should receive a claim, make sure insurance companies comply with regulations, and that the policy is covering the policyholders from claims.

  • Insurance Law

    These lawyers are experienced and knowledgeable in insurance law and can represent policyholders and insurance companies whenever a dispute is related to insurance. Policyholders generally hire them when they face settlement issues with the provider regarding their claim.

Cost of Hiring An Insurance Lawyer

The exact cost of hiring an insurance lawyer in the US depends on the geographic location, the experience level of the professional, and the complexity of your case. An insurance lawyer can cost anywhere between $200 and $500 per hour, depending on their region and the lawyer’s reputation. If you hire an attorney practicing in a rural area, you can expect to pay lower hourly fees than what you would pay for legal services in a metropolitan city.

The price you pay for hiring an insurance lawyer also depends significantly on the professional’s fee arrangement for his service. Some attorneys charge a flat fee depending on the type of case or legal assistance you need. Others charge at an hourly rate; the total cost depends on the number of hours the lawyer spends on your matter. It is advisable to discuss the costs and the billing structure in advance to avoid any confusion later.

Sometimes, you can also hire an insurance lawyer on a contingency basis where you don’t need to pay anything to them if you lose. If you win the settlement, the lawyer is getting paid by the insurance provider. Homeowner insurance, property insurance, and other insurance matters are a good fit for this arrangement.

Type Hourly Flat Fees Contingency
Bad Faith Insurance Junior Associates: $150-$250/Hr

Partners: $200-$600/Hr
$3,000 To $15,000 Per Case Depending On The Nature, Effort, and Complexity of Each Case 15% to 40% of Settlement Amount or Damages For Amounts < $100,000

15% To 30% of Settlement Amount For Amounts > $100,000
Insurance Defense Junior Associates: $175-$225/Hr

Partner: $450-$600/Hr
$7,500 To $100,000 Per Case, Depending On the Nature, Complexity, and Experience of The Attorney 40% of Settlement Amount < $100,000


Compensation or bonus based on certain targets and benchmarks
Insurance Law Junior Associates: $150-$250/Hr

Partner: $300-$450/Hr
$1,500 To $10,000 Based On The Nature & Complexity of Each Case Additional Filing, Court Costs and Other Expenses 33%-40% of Settlement Amount < $100,000

15%-20% of Settlement Amount > $100,000

How To Choose The Right Insurance Lawyer For Your Requirements?

Your choice of an insurance lawyer determines whether or not you receive the settlement you deserve. Therefore it is important that you choose the attorney wisely after taking into consideration all the factors that you feel are crucial. One of the best ways to get started is to get recommendations from family and friends. Ask people around you for some suggestions based on their experience.

You can browse online directories and the state bar association listing to get some good options. Once you have shortlisted options, refine your choices based on similar cases. You should also check online reviews to find lawyers with a proven track record of winning claim disputes. Do your research to learn more about the attorneys and choose a few passionate professionals you think to possess the knowledge and dedication required to win your case.

As you narrow down your options, see that the lawyers you schedule a consultation with have previously handled cases like yours. Take time to do your homework, and you can find somebody who can represent you the best as you fight for the insurance claim that you deserve.


Things You Need To Know Before Talking To An Insurance Lawyer

Once you have decided that you need the assistance of an insurance lawyer for your legal matter, the next step is to find the right professional to represent yourself before the court. Usually, a free consultation is offered by most attorneys, where you can discuss the case, the possible outcomes, and the options available. You can use this meeting to learn more about the lawyer and decide whether you want to work with them for your insurance-related matter.

However, there are a few things you should be aware of before meeting the insurance lawyer for the first time.

  • Your reason for getting a lawyer

    There are situations where you may require the help of an insurance lawyer. You should, however, understand whether hiring a lawyer would get you what you desire and deserve. Clear your needs and expectations make it easier to communicate with the lawyer and make the right choice.

  • Your budget

    Legal services can sometimes be expensive, particularly when choosing a highly reputed professional in an urban area. Analyze your situation to understand how much you want to spend on legal assistance before you start looking for options. If your insurance issue is not so complex but needs some help dealing with it, you can hire a junior associate who charges an affordable price.

    Also, please find out how much the lawyer charges for similar cases and their preferred billing structure. If your budget doesn’t permit hiring a lawyer for a claim, you can always look for professionals willing to take up your case on a contingency basis, where they get paid if you win the lawsuit.

  • Availability of the lawyer

    Before scheduling a consultation, determine whether the attorney you are considering has sufficient time to dedicate to your matter. There is no point in hiring an experienced lawyer who doesn’t find time to answer your questions or work on your case. You can call their office to enquire about their availability. You should also find out whether they promptly respond to messages, calls, and emails. The right lawyer for your insurance matter is somebody who clears all your doubts and explains the technicalities, the possible outcomes of the lawsuit, and other things related to your legal issue.

How To Prepare For An Insurance Law Consultation?

To make the most out of your consultation with the insurance lawyer, prepare before the meeting. During this meeting, the lawyer can help you understand whether you need legal assistance and what to expect from your legal matter concerning the insurance. However, if it is for the first time you are hiring a lawyer to handle your insurance issue, you might not know how to prepare. Let us discuss a few tips to prepare for your insurance law consultation.

Prepare the documents

If you have never dealt with an insurance issue or lawsuit, you might not understand what it takes to prepare for your consultation with the lawyer. Make sure you gather all the documents relevant to the insurance and your details and keep their digital copies ready when you meet the attorney. Your lawyer might give you a list of documents you should produce during the consultation; if not, carry everything you think can be relevant to the case. Here are the essential documents you should take with you to the meeting:

  • Insurance policy papers
  • Relevant medical records
  • Prescriptions and bills
  • Police reports
  • Evidence of the accident or event
  • Witness contacts
  • Proof of lost wages from missing work
  • Personal identity and address proof

Though it can be overwhelming to gather all the documents and bring them with you to the meeting, they can be relevant to your case and help you and the lawyer be on the same page right from the beginning. They can quickly understand the situation and issue and decide if they want to handle the case or not.

Prepare questions to ask the lawyer.

Another way to prepare for your consultation with the insurance lawyer is by knowing what questions you should ask to determine if they are the right fit for you and the insurance claim. Interviewing the lawyer also helps them understand how serious you are about the case and what steps you are willing to take to achieve the desired result.

Make sure you note down all the questions you think you want to ask the attorney to learn about their expertise, experience level, skills, and reputation. You can include some questions that give you insight into the possible results of your matter or issue and the effects the lawyer has achieved for cases like yours. During the meeting, don’t hesitate to ask about the fees and the pricing structure.

Your attorney would ask questions about yourself and the insurance situation to understand the case. It is essential to know that you will not be the only one asking questions at the consultation; you should also stay prepared to answer any questions. Even if you find some questions difficult, you must answer them honestly.


When do I need an insurance lawyer??

The service of an insurance lawyer can be helpful when you need advice about insurance matters or when the insurance company disagrees with paying your claim. You can also seek the help of an insurance lawyer whenever you face a conflict with the insurance provider or find it challenging to understand the terms or policies.

How to find the right insurance lawyer?

To find the perfect insurance lawyer for your situation, you can look for options through state listings and online directories or get referrals from friends, family, and other lawyers. Get past clients to recommend their experience with the lawyers, check their reputation and expertise, and interview them to find somebody you think can best handle your case.

How much does it cost to hire an insurance lawyer?

Insurance lawyers can either work on a contingency basis or charge an hourly or flat fee for the case. The hourly rate varies based on the attorney’s experience, location, and type of case. You can expect to pay anywhere between $200-$400 per hour for hiring an insurance lawyer in the US. Consider that these rates can go high depending on the complexity of the case and the attorney’s reputation.


Finding the right insurance lawyer is crucial if you want to fight for your rights and insurance claim. Though it seems to be daunting at first, all it takes is some research and a decision to have an expert by your side who can protect your best interests when trying to navigate insurance-related matters and issues.

Contact Us
Let us find the best lawyer for you
Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.

Table of Content

Insurance Lawyer Search